Trick or What? Santa Who?

I went trick or treating only once. I was twelve and we had just moved to a California suburb. I borrowed one of my Dad's suits, stuffed a pillow down my front to simulate a beer belly, and headed out with my neighborhood buddies. But first, I had to make sure that Mom and Dad were stocked with candy, prepped to answer the doorbell promptly, and instructed about the proper method of doling out treats.

American holidays are challenging for immigrant kids. They underline how "foreign" your parents are, make you feel guilty for wanting to participate in the fun, and remind you of your status as an outsider, a stranger, a wannabe. Fusing the old and the new is hard work, but two picture books give kids like these -- and their parents -- hope that it's worth the effort.

In Shy Mama's Halloween (Tilbury House, 2000), by Anne Broyles, four Russian children long to go trick-or-treating, but their mother is hesitant. "But I don't know this -- this Halloween," she protests. She prepares their costumes anyway, and the children wait excitedly for Papa to take them out, but he returns home from work with the flu. Bravely, the children face their disappointment as they watch other kids fill the streets with laughter and excitement. But shy Mama rises to the challenge, ties on her scarf, and leads them out into the strange, foreign five-senses experience of Halloween. This beautiful book, illustrated by Leane Morin, reveals the best part of this American holiday -- the chance to connect with neighbors and offer hospitality to one another. An insightful study guide for parents and teachers is included, making the story a great Halloween readaloud for any classroom, especially those with one or two immigrant kids.

Yoon (of My Name is Yoon fame) faces a similar dilemma in Yoon and the Christmas Mitten (FSG, November 2006), when she wants to hang up a stocking but her Korean parents remind her that they "are not a Christmas family." Sensitively and graciously, Helen Recorvits captures the struggle of a young child who longs to participate in American life and honor her parents at the same time. Yoon's parents' efforts to bridge the gap between cultures reveals the imagination and flexibility needed to fuse two traditions. Gabi Swiatkowska begins the illustrations with Yoon looming over her mother and standing apart from the much-smaller figures of schoolfriends playing in the snow. By the end of the book, everyone is the same size, with a smiling, lovely Yoon smack in the center of every spread.

My own struggles during the holidays have helped me to see that they can be some of the loneliest times of the year, even for "land-where-my-fathers-died" kinds of Americans. On Halloween, a friendless child is reminded of his outcast status as other kids head off in joyous clusters. At Christmas, an elderly widow feels bereaved again as she gazes out of her nursing home window to the Christmas tree lights in windows where families are feasting. I'm thankful now for the alienation I felt and how it informs my fiction, because as Kathleen Norris points out in The Cloister Walk:
When artists discover as children that they have inappropriate responses to events around them, they also find, as they learn to trust those responses, that these oddities are what constitute their value to others.


Anonymous said…
I just discovered your blog and site and am sure I will return again and again. I have been between two cultures living outside the States for over 20 years. I have two chidren who are growing up between Japan and the U.S.

Over the years, we've had a full calendar with the celebrations from both cultures. I've been fortunate to have my in-laws downstairs to help with Japanese customs. Being outside, I've been able to choose how festive to be. I've gone through the motions (and had to improvise)and it's been fun to see American holidays through different eyes.
Your post about Halloween reminded me of my children's only experience trick or treating in the States. Chatting with a mom who opened her door I confided that it was their first time. She didn't miss a beat saying, "Oh, honey, it's a weird one!"
Your post and the books you've reviewed have gotten me thinking about how immigrants must view Halloween (esp). Thanks. I'm happy to have found your site and books. Annie Donwerth Chikamatsu
Mitali Perkins said…
Annie, thanks for stopping by. I visited your blog (loved the photos, so interesting) and followed the link to SCBWI Tokyo Chapter. I hope your upcoming writer's event is a huge success -- it certainly sounds like a well-planned and delightful day. Stay in touch, and come back to comment frequently.
Anonymous said…
Actually we're having a Halloween party so I'll miss the meeting. We're having another good one coming up in November. David Schwartz, Lynn Reid Banks and Linda Gerber will visit. congratualtions on your good reviews. annie
Anonymous said…
This is a wonderful and interesting (and informative) post Mitali. Thank you.